Resilient income
Giving income a tactical edge
A long-term income strategy does not have to be static. Our research suggests that modest adjustments to a portfolio of dividend-paying equities and investment-grade bonds could have improved returns over time with only a small increase in volatility.
Key takeaways
- In an illustrative example covering 2001–2026, buying more of investments that had gained over the previous six months and reducing those that had lost value improved the results of a model portfolio of global highdividend shares and investmentgrade bonds.
- Adjusting share and bond holdings separately helped spread risk because their trends often changed at different times. The benefit was not simply a change in how much the portfolio was exposed to markets.
- Our research found that these adjustments helped most when markets fell over several months, as in 2008 and 2022. They were less effective in the sudden market decline of 2020.
Income investors face a balancing act. Staying invested to capture long-term returns, while responding to changing markets. Can they do both without giving up their long-term investment plan?
We explored that question using a model portfolio split equally between high-dividend global equities and investment-grade credit. We then used a simple rule to adjust the investments: buy more when prices have been rising and sell some when they have been falling. We compared this with leaving the portfolio’s allocation unchanged.
While the exercise was limited and illustrative only, the results were encouraging. A 15-percentage-point adjustment increased the portfolio’s annualised return by almost a single percentage point over 2001–2026. Volatility, a measure of the size of the portfolio’s ups and downs, rose only slightly, from 9.5% to 9.7%.
We call this approach “stractical”: keeping a long-term investment plan while making small adjustments along the way. The target mix of investments stays the same; the rule adjusts how much is held around that target.
The value of being strategic: grounded in income that lasts
Start with income that lasts. We use the MSCI World High Dividend Yield Index1 as the universe for equity income as it focuses on companies that generate enough cash to sustain and potentially grow their payouts. Our research shows that large companies in the top fifth by free cash flow yield have outperformed the universe as a whole by 4.5 percentage points a year since 1952, and by 3.6 points a year over the last five years. Free cash flow therefore provides a sound foundation for a disciplined dividend approach. Cash-backed durability comes first and yield follows from it.
On the credit side, the income comes from coupons paid by investmentgrade issuers, selected for their credit quality.
Once the portfolio’s building blocks are in place, the next step is to stay disciplined. Missing only the 10 best trading days since 2001, roughly one in every 670, would have cut the portfolio’s annual return from 5.6% to 4.1%. Missing the 30 best days would have cut it to 2.4%, less than half of the full-period figure.
These best days tend to arrive in the middle of the worst periods: the 2008 US and European bank rescues, the EU and IMF package of May 2010 and the stimulus rally of March 2020. Investors who reduce risk in a crisis can miss the sessions that drive the recovery. That is the practical case for holding the strategic allocation steady through market stress.
A key value of holding the equities and credit sleeves is that their income streams depend on different drivers. Dividends follow corporate earnings and payout decisions, while coupons depend on issuer strength, interest rates and credit spreads. Holding both means the portfolio’s income does not rely on a single source. It also means the two sleeves often trend in different directions, which, as the next section shows, gives the tactical layer more to work with.
The value of tactical adjustment: the case for momentum
A steady allocation can still benefit from a measured adjustment. Our rule is deliberately simple: we assess the return of each half of the portfolio over the previous six months, giving equities and credit their own momentum signals. A positive signal increases the holding in that asset by 15 percentage points; a negative signal reduces it by 15 percentage points, with the difference held in, or borrowed at the J.P. Morgan three-month USD cash rate. We call these changes in holdings tactical adjustment or tilt. The two signals often point in different directions (see Exhibit 1), so the rule adds diversification as well as adjusting overall exposure.
Exhibit 1: The high-dividend and credit signals change direction at different times for most of our study
Source: AllianzGI research, MSCI, Bloomberg, J.P. Morgan. Data as at 30 September 2026.
For illustrative purposes only.
Annual returns over 2001 to 2026 were 6.6% with the tilt, compared to 5.7% without it. The Sharpe ratio, the return earned per unit of risk, was 0.44 with the tilt compared to 0.36 without it. Volatility increased only slightly (see Exhibit 2). In dollar terms, USD 1 invested in 2001 grew to USD 5.1 with the tilt against USD 4.1 without it (see Exhibit 3).
Exhibit 2: Annual returns and the Sharpe ratio were higher with the tilt, while volatility was slightly higher
Source: AllianzGI research, MSCI, Bloomberg, J.P. Morgan. Data as at 30 September 2026.
For illustrative purposes only.
Exhibit 3: A small tactical tilt increased the portfolio’s growth over our study
Source: AllianzGI research, MSCI, Bloomberg, J.P. Morgan. Data as at 30 September 2026.
For illustrative purposes only.
The three periods of most market stress show where the tactical adjustment earned its keep (see Exhibit 4). During the 2008 global financial crisis and 2022 rate shock, markets fell steadily over many months. By the time of the steepest losses in 2008, both halves of the portfolio had already posted negative returns over the previous six months. In 2022, the same was true of the credit half. In each case, the rule had already reduced exposure to the holdings with negative six-month returns. During the 2020 Covid-19 sell-off, the fall took only a few weeks, too fast for a six-month signal to respond. The rule therefore is most effective in declines that develop over several months and investors should not expect it to protect them against sudden shocks.
Exhibit 4: Our six-month momentum rule was most effective in declines that develop over several months
Source: AllianzGI research, MSCI, Bloomberg, J.P. Morgan. Data as at 30 September 2026.
For illustrative purposes only.
The tilt’s contribution was almost unrelated to how the strategic portfolio itself performed (a correlation of -0.1). In other words, it behaved like a separate source of return (see Exhibit 5). Its rolling 36-month correlation varies widely with market conditions, from +0.9 in 2005–2007 to -0.8 in 2009–2011, and is negative in about a third of all windows. It was most useful after the 2008 and 2022 falls, when it moved independently of, or against, the core portfolio, providing genuine diversification.
Exhibit 5: The tilt’s contribution was almost unrelated to how the strategic portfolio itself performed
Source: AllianzGI research, MSCI, Bloomberg, J.P. Morgan. Data as at 30 September 2026.
For illustrative purposes only.
The tactical portfolio’s advantage was uneven over time. It had the higher Sharpe ratio in 46% of rolling 36-month periods. It led the strategiconly portfolio clearly through the 2008–2011 crisis and recovery, kept pace for most of 2012–2020, and trailed it modestly over the last two to three years (see Exhibit 6). We see the tactical adjustment as a long-run advantage, earned mainly during periods of stress and recovery, rather than something that pays every year. That raises the question of whether a bigger tilt would add further value.
Exhibit 6: We see the tactical tilt as a long-run advantage, earned mainly during periods of stress and recovery
Source: AllianzGI research, MSCI, Bloomberg, J.P. Morgan. Data as at 30 September 2026.
For illustrative purposes only.
The value of restraint: the case for a small tilt
We applied the same rule at four tilt sizes (zero, ±15%, ±30% and ±50%) to compare the extra return and risk from each increase. The first 15 percentage points of tilt were by far the most efficient: they added almost a full percentage point of annual return for just 0.2 percentage points of extra volatility. Increasing the tilt from ±15% to ±30% added 0.8 percentage points of return and 0.8 percentage points of volatility. Moving from ±30% to ±50% added another percentage point of return for almost two more percentage points of volatility. The Sharpe ratio still edged up, but the gains flattened while the portfolio’s risk profile changed materially.
For investors whose risk budget is defined by the 50/50 strategic allocation, a ±15% tilt therefore looks like the right balance (see Exhibit 7). It improves returns over time while keeping the portfolio’s risk close to that of the strategic portfolio.
Exhibit 7: A ±15% tilt looks like the right balance for investors in a 50/50 strategic allocation
Source: AllianzGI research, MSCI, Bloomberg, J.P. Morgan. Data as at 30 September 2026.
For illustrative purposes only.
Keeping income strategic and tactics modest
Income investors do not have to choose between discipline and flexibility. A durable strategic core provides the income, and a small, rules-based tactical adjustment can add value around it without turning the portfolio into a market-timing exercise.
We see the tactical adjustment as a modest refinement of a sound income allocation, rather than a replacement of it.
1 The MSCI World High Dividend Yield Index tracks large- and mid-cap equities across developed markets countries that offer above-average, sustainable, and persistent dividend yields relative to the broader MSCI World Index.